If you've been around here a while you may recall that last year’s holidays were not happy ones for me. I’m hoping to change that this year by more fully embracing the spirit and the message of this joyous season.
My life is different now, but I can look back on more than 50 wonderful Thanksgiving and Christmas celebrations. Some do get more, but some get fewer and sadly some don’t get any at all. So, I’m grateful for what I’ve received, and one way to express that is to celebrate some of my favorite holiday Comfort TV episodes. We’re still in November so let’s start with two Thanksgiving classics.
That Girl
Thanksgiving Comes But Once a Year, Hopefully”
The dilemma faced in this episode is one shared by many, whether in 1967 when this show aired or in 2026: where should we spend the holiday? Ann’s parents want her with them in Brewster, while Don’s parents want him to come home to St. Louis. Ann and Don would prefer to have Thanksgiving dinner together, so the only solution is to have everyone gather in Ann’s apartment.
Does it go smoothly? If it did it wouldn’t be much of an episode. Before dinner can be served doors are broken, the fire department is called, and both dads will be coping with injuries that may linger through Christmas morning.
All the farcical complications are fun, but it’s the smaller, quieter moments that I most enjoy.
Ann’s father (wonderfully played by Lew Parker) telling her how her mother’s eyes shine when she thinks her daughter still needs her to iron her clothes.
The menu preparation – how to accommodate the favorite holiday dishes of six different people.
The two fathers comparing notes on their World War II service.
And then there’s Mabel Albertson, most famous to classic TV fans as Darrin’s mother on Bewitched. Here she plays Don’s mother with the same fussy manner, once again barely masking her disappointment at her son’s choice of significant other.
But of course – no spoiler alert necessary – the final scene ends with smiles and laughter all around, providing one more reason so many of us keep returning to the classics.
The Bob Newhart Show
“Over the River and Through the Woods”
When lists are released of the funniest sitcom episodes, any that leaves this episode out of the top ten should not be taken seriously.
As with the That Girl episode, it’s an in-law situation that launches the plot. Emily wants to visit her family in Seattle for Thanksgiving. Bob had agreed to go along but is having second thoughts, citing the convenient excuse that holidays are tough times for his patients and he should stay close to home. Emily has heard it all before and heads to Seattle alone.
But Bob isn’t alone – Jerry, Howard, and Mr. Carlin all wind up at his place, along with a frozen-solid turkey and a jug of spiked cider. Bob Newhart, Bill Daily, Jack Riley and Peter Bonerz were handed a scene in which their characters get sloshed over Thanksgiving. They hit their rhythm early and for ten minutes set-ups and punch lines are served and volleyed with perfect timing and precision, culminating in the most hilarious attempt to order Chinese food (“More goo to go!”) in the history of television.
In 1997, the TV Guide ranked this episode number 9 on its "100 Greatest Episodes of All Time" list. It was one of three Bob Newhart Show episodes written by Bruce Kane, who then spent the 1980s writing more than 40 episodes of Small Wonder. Go figure. But his mind and his pen delivered a comedic masterpiece for the ages, and if he’s like most writers, he’ll be content with that.
Happy Thanksgiving from Comfort TV!























